At least not in Italy
Walk into any kitchen in Capolona, the small farming town in Arezzo, Tuscany where our grove sits, and you will not find two bottles of olive oil. One for cooking, one for finishing. There is one bottle. It gets used for everything. Frying an egg, roasting vegetables, drizzling over a finished dish, dipping bread, taking a spoon in the morning. The same oil, the same bottle, the same pour every time.
The distinction between finishing olive oil and cooking olive oil is an American marketing construct. In Italy it does not exist. To the people who have been making and using olive oil for generations in Capolona, there is only one category of olive oil worth producing or consuming. Extra virgin. Everything else is for the rest of the world.
What Extra Virgin Actually Means
Extra virgin olive oil is defined by two things: how it is made and its acidity level. It must be extracted mechanically without heat or chemicals, from the first pressing of the olives, and its free acidity must be below 0.8%. That is it. That is the definition.
At the mills we use in Capolona there is no second pressing. The olives go in, the oil comes out, and the solid byproduct gets loaded into semi truck trailers parked outside. There is a joke among the people at the mill about those trailers. They say that is the olive oil going to America.
It is a joke. It is also not entirely a joke. That byproduct gets sold in bulk and what happens to it after it leaves the mill is anyone's guess. Whether it gets pressed again somewhere, mixed with genuine extra virgin oil, or sold under a label that implies something it is not -- nobody at the mill can tell you for certain. What they can tell you is that it never touches the oil that goes into their certified containers. At these mills the first pressing is the only pressing and the byproduct is the byproduct.
So when an American brand labels one product "finishing oil" and sells it at a premium over their "cooking oil" the question worth asking is: what exactly is the cooking oil? If finishing oil is extra virgin, first pressed, cold extracted -- which by definition it has to be to carry that label -- then what is the cooking oil that sits next to it on the shelf? The answer is that it is a lower grade product being sold alongside a premium one, and the premium label is doing the work of making the whole shelf look legitimate.
In Italy you would not find that shelf. The people in Capolona would not understand the question.
Why People Think You Should Only Finish With Good Oil
The logic most people follow goes something like this. This oil cost $40. I am not going to fry eggs in a $40 bottle of oil. I will save it for drizzling over finished dishes where I can actually taste it.
This is understandable. It is also based on a misunderstanding of what makes high quality olive oil valuable in the first place.
The reason our oil costs what it costs is not because it is too precious to cook with. It is because of everything that went into making it. A hundred olive trees harvested by hand in October at peak polyphenol content. Cold pressed within hours at our local mill. Stored in oxygen sealed containers in a hillside cellar. Bottled in ceramic and air freighted to the US within a week. The price reflects the work, the quality, and the honesty of the process. It does not reflect a rule about how you are allowed to use it.
Think about how people justify paying more for other foods. Organic produce over conventional. Grass fed beef over grain fed. A ten year old wine over a two year old one. Brown eggs over white. People pay the premium because they perceive or actually notice a difference in quality. Sometimes the difference is real and significant. Sometimes it is marginal. But the decision to pay more is almost always justified by the belief that the better product does something the cheaper one does not.
High quality extra virgin olive oil from a known single source with real polyphenol content does something the cheaper oil does not. The health benefits, the flavor, the fat quality -- these are real differences, not marketing. And those benefits do not disappear when you use the oil to cook rather than finish. You are still getting a better fat, with more good nutrients, in your food. Whether that food is drizzled with oil at the table or fried in it at the stove.
What Happens When You Actually Cook With It
The French fry test is the most dramatic example I can give you. French fries made in our olive oil come out with a crispness and a golden color that I have not been able to replicate with any other oil. The higher fat content of real extra virgin olive oil behaves differently in heat than the thin, processed oils most people cook with. The result is food that cooks better, not just food that tastes better when you drizzle oil on it at the end.
Roasted vegetables get a deeper color and crispier edges. A fried egg cooked in good olive oil develops those lacy, crisp edges around the white that you see in Italian cooking and cannot quite achieve with butter or neutral oil. The oil is doing something in the pan that cheaper oil does not do, because the fat content and quality is genuinely different.
This is not surprising if you think about it. Cooking is chemistry. Better ingredients produce different chemical results. The same reason grass fed butter behaves differently from standard butter in a pan is the same reason high polyphenol extra virgin olive oil behaves differently from commodity olive oil. The quality of the fat matters before it hits the food and after.
Use the oil however works for you. Take a spoon every morning. Drizzle it on a finished steak. Cook your eggs in it, roast your vegetables, fry your french fries. The only wrong way to use it is to leave it on a shelf being saved for a special occasion that never comes.
There is no finishing olive oil in Italy. There is just olive oil. Use it.
Shop the Current Harvest
Safadi Farm, Capolona, Arezzo, Tuscany